IS FRANCHISING HIGHLY REGULATED? Top Franchisee Attorneys Weigh In
“Prospective franchisees can feel safe investing in a franchise,” many a franchise salesman has stated, “Because franchising is highly regulated, and there are severe penalties for non-compliance.”
The International Franchise Association and other opponents of franchisee-protection legislation also argue that franchising is already a “highly regulated industry.”
This contention seems highly suspect considering the many blatant stories on UnhappyFranchisee.Com of shady companies that violate franchise disclosure laws with impunity, and established franchisors who seem to hold all the cards in the franchise relationship.
So we are asking the nation’s top franchisee attorneys: “Is Franchising Highly Regulated?”
![]() |
Cary Ichter – Ichter Thomas (Profile)“There is, for all practical purposes, no franchise regulation on the Federal level because the FTC has nullified its own regulations through its lack of enforcement and by not allowing for a private right of action… even when its regulations have been clearly violated. “Regulations having to do with selling franchises typically come from the FTC Franchise Rule and the FTC apparently doesn’t have the resources to enforce that rule, or even go after franchises that are out there pulling some sort of scam. The FTC, as far as I can tell, doesn’t do much of anything to enforce franchising regulations.” Read: Attorney Cary Ichter: There is No Federal Franchise Regulation |
![]() |
Jon Fortman – Fortman Law (Profile)
”Franchisors use the line that franchise industries are ‘highly regulated’ as a ploy to ease investors’ anxieties. However, it is our experience that the exact opposite is true. Franchisees commonly mistake the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) as protecting their investment. When in fact, the FTC merely provides rules with no means of enforcement. It is only after a franchisee has been defrauded that he or she quickly realizes the FTC Franchise Rule does not provide them with a private cause of action. Not to mention, the FTC also does nothing to regulate the information contained in Franchise Disclosure Documents. While it may have rules and regulations for franchisors, they are merely used as smoke screens for franchisors to withhold pertinent information from its investors. “Furthermore, in twenty-four states, franchise registration is not even required, but the FTC Franchise Rule must be followed, which provides minimal protection for franchisees. There are some states that have franchisee protection statutes, nonetheless they still do not provide enough protection. While some protection is better than none, these still do not provide the franchise industry with the status of ‘highly regulated.’ No one is there to enforce the rules leaving the franchise industry rife with fraud. The need for the franchise industry to be not only highly regulated, but regulated at all, has been long overdue.” |
![]() |
Peter C. Lagarias – Lagarias Law Offices
|
![]() |
Howard Bundy – Bundy Law PLLC
|
![]() |
Stanley M. Dub – Stanley M. Dub Co. LPA
|
![]() |
Richard A. Solomon”Franchising is not a regulated industry in any real sense, It has to deal with certain “paperwork” laws requiring FDDs and registrations, but these laws have no enforcement teeth because they are all unfunded mandates. Enforcement is left to private civil litigation in over 99 % of situations. The claim that it is regulated is just a convenient sales pitch for those who don’t know what regulation is. By comparison, parking your car overtime on a parking meter is a regulated activity – far more so than franchising.” |
![]() |
Josh Brown“Most people I meet with do believe that the industry is policed more than it actually is. They usually are not so sure about the regulations, but they erroneously believe that the stack of docs they receive that make up the FDD & other related agreements somehow legitimizes the franchisor… They unfortunately believe that the FDD contains everything that they need to know, and they blindly believe what is told to them by franchisors. I really don’t think, though, that the myth of the highly policed nature of franchises is that damaging… It may serve as some sort of comfort to them when they are told how highly regulated the industry is, but I really don’t believe it moves the decision-making meter. More of a danger is the damaging way in which some franchisors seduce would-be buyers to believe that the systems are better organized and more profitable than they actually are, which is is just downright misleading and unethical.” Read Attorney Josh Brown: Legal Docs Don’t Legitimize a Franchisor |
![]() |
Louis A. Sousa”Laws are in place but the protections do not go far enough to protect franchisee’s interests. Repeated attempts to balance them in the legislative process are vigorously fought by the franchisors. For example, few states have laws requiring a franchisor to renew a franchise agreement at its expiration, stripping an otherwise compliant franchisee of value as term expires. Few state laws restrict termination of a franchise agreement to good cause shown. Within the last decade Rhode Island’s legislature passed a law expanding franchisee rights and the franchisor lobby immediately descended upon the state house resulting in a substantial withering of the statute.”
|
![]() |
Terrence Dunn“Government regulation does not presume governmental oversight. Government regulation and/or oversight in an open economy should be employed judiciously and is never a substitute for intelligent due diligence and careful legal advice. The franchise landscape is regulated in the sense that all offerings are supposed to follow a rigid format. There is little oversight. The law is applied in different states in varying ways and it has little teeth to it. There is room for the unscrupulous to take advantage of the unwary. That is always the case in a free market. Too many cases arise because buyers don’t fully investigate the presented opportunity. That is avoidable. Hire a good franchise lawyer.” |
![]() |
Dan Davis – Ichter Thomas LLC (Profile)”Franchising is a highly-regulated industry, but the nature of that regulation is limited in ways that prospective franchisees may not understand. The Federal Trade Commission’s (‘FTC’) Franchise and Business Opportunities Rule imposes extensive disclosure requirements on franchisors. The FTC’s Compliance Guide, for example, is 154 pages long. It is important to understand, however, that the Franchise Rule does not regulate the substance of franchise agreements. All the Franchise Rule does is to require franchisors to disclose certain information so prospective franchisees can make more informed (and therefore presumably better) decisions.”
|
![]() |
Mitchell Kassoff“The first answer to that question is yes, franchising really is a highly regulated industry. There is a very detailed Franchise Disclosure Document required to be given to each prospective franchisee, plus registration requirements in many states. “The second answer to that question is the effect of this regulation. It is time consuming and expensive to draft a Franchise Disclosure Document and then to have it registered in the states that require registration, especially since each state requiring registration has its own special requirements. The result is a detailed and complex document that is so detailed and complex that many prospective franchisees give up and don’t even bother to read it. The effect of this regulation is an expensive document, that many prospective franchisees don’t read and which increases the cost to purchase a franchise.” |
Check back as we add more responses from top franchisee attorneys and other franchise insiders.
Visit our Directory of Franchise Attorneys.
WHAT DO YOU THINK? IS FRANCHISING “HIGHLY REGULATED” AS THE IFA AND FRANCHISE SALESPEOPLE CLAIM? SHARE YOUR OPINION BELOW.
TAGS: Franchise regulations, franchise laws, franchise law firms, franchise lawyers, franchise lawyer, franchise compliance, state franchise laws, federal franchise laws, franchise law, franchise attorneys, franchisee attorneys, franchise myths, is franchising safe?, franchise lawsuits, franchise failure rates, franchise complaints, franchise problems
The post IS FRANCHISING HIGHLY REGULATED? Top Franchisee Attorneys Weigh In appeared first on Unhappy Franchisee. Reposting this content without prior expressed written permission by Relentless, Inc. is strictly prohibited.