Kumon educational franchise owner David Joseph originally posted the following as a comment on the post KUMON Franchise Owner Complains of Overexpansion. We’ve moved it here because of length, the quality of the content and the importance of the franchise issues Mr. Joseph raises. Please feel free to share your opinions below.
Comments from David Joseph, NJ Kumon Franchise Owner
Hello, My name is David Joseph and I own a minority share in a center located in NJ. I’m putting up this post to make my views plain and clear to everyone. My statements here are mine and mine alone. I’m concerned about Kumon’s strategy. I’m not concerned about issues involving associations, products, services, or contracts. I also don’t care about rants and insults that are now popping up on this page.
I’m concerned about Kumon’s strategy because I’m seeing encroachment and cannibalization. Although I’m not affected by encroachment, I directly and indirectly know people that are, as I believe we all do. For owners that are not directly affected now, you may be affected in a few months or a few years because of Kumon’s strategy and implementation plan.
For those who don’t own a center, think of encroachment and cannibalization as a pay cut or a layoff. I use this analogy because you lose money and, in the worst case, you can lose your job.
Kumon’s strategy is to build brand awareness through expansion. In essence make Kumon a household name because there will, so to speak, be a Kumon on every corner.
When I think of educational companies with great brand awareness, I think of Sylvan. However, I don’t see a Sylvan on every corner. In North America, there are approximately 1100 Sylvan centers. Kumon has approximately 1500 centers in North America. Yet the average person is more familiar with Sylvan than they are with Kumon.
Sylvan’s brand awareness was developed through heavy TV advertisement. TV ads and spots can cost a lot of money. The money used for advertisement directly affects Sylvan’s bottom line because that money comes directly out of the corporate budget. Sylvan corporate took a financial risk because they invested corporate money into advertising. I’m not sure what Sylvan’s return on investment was but I feel safe to say they achieved their brand awareness goal.
Kumon’s brand awareness strategy is based on increasing the number of centers. Speaking strictly from a corporate viewpoint, it is a brilliant strategy in terms of capital and return on investment. The majority of the money needed to expand comes from owners buying new center locations. New centers may end up encroaching on existing centers but from the corporate viewpoint that is OK. Corporate believes that there will be an overall increase in enrollment. Again, strictly from a corporate viewpoint, there is a lot of upside with minimal financial risk. The risk, from a corporate view, is generating vocal owners. These vocal owners will limit Kumon’s ability to attract new franchisees.
In order for Kumon to justify expansion, they must justify that the market can handle more centers. That is why I questioned and will continue to question the assumptions used to justify expansion. For current owners, take the time to understand your local market in terms of the number of potential students, family income of the students attending your center(s), where they live, etc and estimate what your market penetration rate is. Your concerns and challenges will be dismissed by corporate if you do not come with hard facts. You will also be more confident when you raise issues.
From the franchisee view, expansion can be positive or negative. It is positive if you are operating in an unsaturated market. However, it is especially dangerous if you have large center(s) or if your center(s) are in a saturated market(s). There are centers in NJ that have lost 100+ subjects because a new center opened up in close proximity. Although those centers are very large, loosing 100+ subjects is a huge hit on the profitability of those centers. This is why some owners, especially in NJ, are very concerned about Kumon’s expansion strategy. For owners that operate in less saturated markets, please understand that if left unchecked, expansion will turn from a positive to a negative very quickly.
I put posts on twitter that eventually resulted in postings on unhappyfranchisee.com. I did not hide my name so that Kumon corporate can find me. Eventually corporate contacted me and we had a heated discussion. To be honest, I was too heated to articulate the reasons I chose to post on twitter so here goes:
1) I wanted to demonstrate how much attention only 1 owner can generate and therefore the true risk of Kumon’s strategy.
2) I wanted to be a voice for those who are concerned about expansion and could not get their voice heard.
3) I wanted to give potential franchisees information on some unstated/understated risks of owning a Kumon center.
4) I wanted to demonstrate the effectiveness of utilizing a low cost alternative media channels.
On point 4, let me be more specific. I don’t have a lot of followers on twitter, yet I managed to reach a very broad audience. How did I do it? I spent a few hours finding my target audience. In this case it was Kumon franchising personal, certain franchising experts, and a few owners that actually used twitter. I crafted messages that spoke to different segments and the rest is history. My point here is that my upfront time was figuring out my goals, figuring out who I should target, and crafting messages to get the results I wanted. It only took a few hours over a weekend to generate the buzz.
Now think about Kumon’s customers. Imagine if Kumon corporate invested the resources into understanding customers segments and helping franchisees reach those segments. That is why I challenged Kumon to gain a better understanding of their customers and develop customer segments. I sincerely believe it is a better investment to gain an in-depth understanding of customers and reach people that will truly value Kumon’s offer rather than simply saturating a market.
In addition, the cost to build brand awareness has dropped dramatically. It is not necessary to spend a lot of money on traditional media to reach a targeted audience. Kumon is a word of mouth business and right now word of mouth can be multiplied 1000 fold by utilizing social media. I’m not saying that every Kumon owner needs to get on twitter. I believe it is actually more effective for Kumon corporate to invest their resources into developing a social media plan. Kumon corporate already knows there is something to it because a lot of Kumon’s franchising team already utilizes twitter to attract potential franchisees.
Take aways:
Kumon owners – Don’t just talk about how you lost business to a new center because corporate does not see that as big picture issue. Think in terms of corporate goals, strategies and assumptions used to justify corporate goals and strategies. There are a lot of assumptions that can be challenged. Do your homework and your challenges will carry more weight. If you decide to use public online outlets, do not get yourself dragged into taunts and fights. It’s a waste of your time. Utilize public forums to draw attention to your concerns about Kumon’s expansion strategy. Its not just about you, it’s about everyone that owns a Kumon center.
Kumon Corporate – The expansion strategy has a lot of financial upside but it is very risky if continue to alienate owners. More and more owners will utilize public forums to express their opinions about expansion. NJ is only one market. Imagine if owners in other markets start doing the same thing. Imagine the affect on franchisee recruitment.
The cost of building brand awareness is a lot lower now than just a few years ago due to alternative media channels. If the goal is to build brand awareness, social medial is an effective low cost tool to reach target customers and build brand awareness.
Potential franchisees – If you found this post, you have received insight that most of the current owners did not have at the time they purchased a franchise. It is an interesting time at Kumon. There is a lot of potential but there is also a lot of risk depending on how Kumon moves forward with their strategy. There are some good posts that can help you make a more informed decision. Work with your franchising people but also seek out information from current owners. Ask current owners the benefits and downsides of owning a franchise. Ask their opinion about Kumon’s strategy. I’m sure there are enough owners out there that will give you their honest opinion. Also, if expansion is limited, you can feel safer about your investment.
Final Thoughts: I’m very passionate about business and Kumon. I believe Kumon offers a good service but my opinion is that Kumon’s expansion strategy will escalate franchise franchisee conflict. Escalated conflict will limit both franchisor and franchisee in reaching their goals.
If you’d like to talk to me directly, please find me on twitter. I’m happy to address any questions or concerns.
Sincerely,
David Joseph
WHAT DO YOU THINK? SHARE A COMMENT BELOW. LOGO: Kumon
